Blue Hill Bay Property Rentals is a locally owned and operated company partnering with property owners on Maine’s beautiful Blue Hill Peninsula. As lifelong residents, we manage a curated selection of quality short-term rental properties—from premier waterfront estates to charming village homes—spanning a variety of sizes, styles, and price points.

We are committed to providing our guests and owners with a professional, straightforward experience built on:

• Transparent Pricing: Honest, upfront rates that include all taxes and fees—with no surprises.
• Property Excellence: Clean, comfortable homes maintained to high standards with prompt, reliable communication.
• Local Expertise: Deep knowledge of the region from a team that has lived here their whole lives.
• Professional Integrity: Quality service and a commitment to respect in every interaction.

All our privately owned rental properties are non-smoking. While amenities vary by property, we offer several dog-friendly homes to ensure the whole family can enjoy the Maine coast.

As trusted members of our local Chamber of Commerce, we take pride in our honesty and the long-term relationships we build within our community. Whether you are a property owner seeking professional management or a guest planning your next stay, we look forward to assisting you.

Contact us today; we look forward to sharing the best of Maine with you.

---

Chelsea Horton | Co-Owner

Chelsea Horton is a lifelong resident and the co-owner of Blue Hill Bay Property Rentals. She possesses an instinctive understanding of the local market and the community dynamics that make this region a premier destination. Her professional background in social services and education has shaped her into a skilled communicator and a dedicated advocate for both property owners and guests.

Chelsea is deeply involved in the evolving local market, offering a hands-on perspective on property management and the practicalities of ownership. She shares this essential knowledge with every client, ensuring they have a steady and focused approach to managing their properties.

As a Real Estate Agent with Harcourts Waterfront & Fine Properties, Chelsea helps clients find their own perfect place in the community, whether they are looking for a primary residence or a vacation rental investment. Chelsea and her family are deeply invested in the Maine lifestyle; whether they are at their camp in the North Maine Woods or closer to home, she finds her greatest joy in enjoying quality family time and helping others discover the community she loves.

---

Brenda Horton | Co-Owner

Brenda Horton is a lifelong resident and the co-owner of Blue Hill Bay Property Rentals. With a professional background in international sales and business, Brenda brings a global perspective and strong business acumen to the local short-term rental market. Her travels only deepened her appreciation for the unique charm and character found in her home state of Maine.

At Blue Hill Bay Property Rentals, Brenda has a front-row seat to the factors that drive market demand and property value. This experience, combined with her pragmatic approach, ensures her clients have a thorough understanding of a property’s true worth in the local market. As a Real Estate Agent with Harcourts Waterfront & Fine Properties, she is uniquely positioned to help buyers and sellers evaluate investment potential and make informed, confident decisions.

Bringing a global perspective and strong business acumen back home, Brenda ensures every transaction is handled with professionalism and attention to detail. She believes that clear data and straightforward advice are the keys to a successful real estate journey, and when she is not assisting clients, she enjoys exploring Maine, gardening, and spending quality time with her family.